Equal Housing Opportunity Broker  |  NY Fair Housing Notice & Standard Operating Procedure ↗
Chautauqua Lake waterfront view

Chautauqua County, New York

Lake life isn't a listing.
It's a decision.

Born Here. Selling Here.

41 years on this water.
Not a market I moved into.

I grew up in Bemus Point. I've spent my whole life on Chautauqua Lake — boating it, swimming it, watching it through every season. I worked at the Chautauqua Institution as a teenager. I ski Ellicottville every winter. When you hire me, you're getting someone who actually knows this place — not someone who Googled it.

My Story
41 Years on Chautauqua Lake
35+ Homes Sold Per Year
6 Active Markets
$0 BS Tolerance

The Markets

Six towns. One agent who knows them all.

Bemus Point
Bemus Point
Gold Coast · Lakefront · Village Life
Explore →
Mayville
Mayville
North End · County Seat · Quiet Lakefront
Explore →
Lakewood
Lakewood
South End · Community · Lake Access
Explore →
Findley Lake
Findley Lake
Private · Peaceful · Four Season
Explore →
Lake Erie
Lake Erie
Twin Lakes · Affordable Entry · Waterfront
Explore →
Ellicottville
Ellicottville
Ski Country · HoliMont · Holiday Valley
Explore →

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ 42+ Five-Star Reviews

Trusted locally. Relied on remotely.

See why buyers and sellers across Chautauqua County trust Property Match USA.

★★★★★

"Tiffany is hands down the best Realtor we have ever used! She is professional, incredibly efficient and amazing with communication. I wish she traveled to Pittsburgh! We would use her in every state!"

Britni Hunkele
Out-of-State Buyer (Pittsburgh)
★★★★★

"Very professional! House was sold in 6 hours, highly recommend Property Match."

Shelly Leathers
Seller Success
★★★★★

"I can't thank Tiffany enough for her exceptional service in helping us buy our home while we were out of state. From start to finish, she made the entire process seamless and stress-free."

Lawrence Mosca
Out-of-State Relocation

Active Listings

Chautauqua Lake homes on the market now.

The data relating to real estate on this website comes in part from the Internet Data Exchange (IDX) Program of the CNYIS, UNYREIS and WNYREIS. Listing Data last updated daily. All information deemed reliable but not guaranteed.

Chautauqua Lake dock lifestyle

This is what you're actually buying.

Chautauqua Lake · Western New York

Tiffany Borst licensed real estate broker

Licensed Real Estate Broker

Tiffany Borst

I grew up in Bemus Point. I've spent 41 years on Chautauqua Lake — boating it, swimming it, watching it change through every season. I worked at the Chautauqua Institution as a teenager. I ski Ellicottville every winter. This isn't a market I moved into. It's home.

When you hire me, you're not getting someone who pulled up Zillow and learned the zip codes. You're getting someone who knows which docks flood in March, which neighborhoods have the best lake access, what deed lake rights actually mean, and which contractors to call.

I tell people the real thing. If a property has a problem, I say so before the inspection. That's not a sales strategy — it's just how I work.

Full Story

Get In Touch

Ready to talk lake real estate?

Buying, selling, or figuring out what your lake home is worth — drop your info and I'll be in touch.

By submitting, I agree to be contacted by PropertyMatch USA LLC via call, email, and text for real estate services. To opt out, you can reply 'STOP' at any time or reply 'HELP' for assistance. You can also click the unsubscribe link in the emails. Message and data rates may apply. Message frequency may vary. View our Privacy Policy.